Search This Blog

Tuesday, March 23, 2010


I have been watching lots of programs about addiction lately. It started innocently with Celebrity Rehab and then I started watching Hoarders and now I am watching Addicted. I don’t watch much TV during the week, but I like to watch these shows while I am folding laundry on Saturday and Sunday. I am not sure why I find these train wrecks so appealing. Maybe it has something to do with my relationship to food and compulsive eating.

I know there is some debate about whether or not compulsive eating is an addiction. I’ve read some other blog entries on the subject and I know most of us here in Blogland seem to be of the opinion that it is an addiction. I pretty much believe that.

Several years ago I attended Overeater’s Anonymous (OA) meetings on a regular basis. OA is a 12-step group modeled after Alcoholic’s Anonymous. When I first attended OA I was not overweight, but I was struggling with feeling really out of control around food. I was also experimenting with purging behaviors. I worked the program and abstained from compulsive eating for three or four months.
At some point during my years as a person with disordered eating behaviors, I discovered the author Geneen Roth. Geneen wrote a book called Breaking Free from Compulsive Eating and several other books that I really enjoyed and found helpful. She does not believe that compulsive overeating is an addiction. Specifically I recall her taking exception with the idea that we are powerless over food, which of course is the first step in a 12-step program. She argues that diets teach us that we are powerless – that we need someone to tell us what to eat and when, but that if we wish to “break free”, we need to reclaim the fact that we do control what we eat and our bodies know when to eat and when to stop eating. Her argument is pretty compelling.

So with Geneen Roth’s influence, I decided that I wasn’t powerless over food, but I was powerless over the compulsion to overeat. A normal eater probably wouldn’t think about eating the way I do. They wouldn’t want to eat when they weren’t hungry. They might make bad food choices from time-to-time, but they wouldn’t chose bad foods as a method of stress relief or boredom relief or as a way to stop feeling things that are uncomfortable. Is this an addiction?

The only other addiction I have had is cigarettes. I was a smoker for many years, beginning as a teen until I was 21 or so. Then I quit until I was 26 and smoked off and on until I was 34. I haven’t smoked for four years. I don’t usually think about smoking or want to smoke. I didn’t want to smoke during the five years between 21 and 26 either, but I starting smoking again because I was going through a difficult break up and I continued smoking because I was addicted. I quit during both of my pregnancies, but smoked again after my kids were born. Much of the time, I only smoked two cigarettes a day which I think demonstrates a stronger mental addiction than physical one.

It some ways the food thing is similar to the smoking addiction. I ate even though I knew it was bad for my health. I sometimes ate badly even when I didn’t really want to. Like the week before my surgery. I did not have to follow a pre-op diet so I made the rounds for my “last meals”. I went to all my favorite lunch places. I went out to dinner at my favorite dinner restaurant. I considered driving 50 miles to Corvalis, Oregon to eat one “last meal” at Burgerville (Sidenote: If you ever find yourself in the Pacific Northwest, you must eat a meal at Burgerville. Their special sauce is so yummy. Be sure to order a side to dip your fries in!). As I was eating all these “last foods”, I had this feeling that I would be so relieved when I didn’t have to do this anymore. Like I was eating like this because I had to and not because I wanted to. Perhaps the biggest similarity that I can see between the two addictions is that I have gone along before on a food plan and thought about how crazy it was to eat like I did before and feel like I cannot imagine eating like that again. But I always resumed those crazy eating habits and then felt like I couldn’t stop – not just that I couldn’t stop, but that I couldn’t even muster the desire to want to stop. Just like the way I quit smoking and went for years without even wanting to smoke and then one day started smoking and found that I couldn’t stop – that I didn’t even want to stop.

This is important for me because right now I am in the space where I cannot imagine resuming those crazy eating habits again. I am losing weight really well. I feel great. I have lost weight and am a bit smaller than before. I am trying to be mindful of the pitfalls and am making plans to deal with them when they come. I am also trying to do different things. The lap band is an obvious difference, but I’ve also signed up for a 10K (I will be walking). Today for the first time ever I rode my bike to work. Unfortunately I probably won’t be able to do this regularly (my kids come to my office after school so there would be the logistical issues of getting their bikes to my office for us all to ride home). But what happens when I don’t feel like following my food plan anymore? What happens when I can’t make myself want to eat well?

I have been watching the shows about addiction for a couple of months now and one of the tidbits I’ve gleaned is something that Dr. Drew said on Celebrity Rehab about addicts creating situations in their lives in which the only way they can deal with it is by using. For example, if they normally use because of stress in their relationships, they might pick a fight with their boy/girlfriend. It scares the hell out of me that I might be creating situations in my own life in which the only way I can cope is by abusing food. I am worried that I can’t trust my own instincts – like my feeling that I may not be ready for my first fill. So I made the appointment for my first fill. It will be next Wednesday. Because if I am an addict and if I am unconsciously setting myself up to be in a position where I might “use” food in a compulsive way, I want to be ready with an effective tool.


Drazil said...

Wow - very insightful. Thanks for posting - I love the addiction shows too - of any kind - they intrigue me and I learn from them even if they don't directly pertain to me. We all have a little addict in us I think.

BanderificBeauty said...

Good job at looking into your brain to see whats going on!!! It takes a hella lot of strength to face issues and try to retrain your brain. You have alot of cheerleaders behind you. Imagine me with my little pom poms rooting you on :)GO AMANDA GO! Your doing great girl keep it up!!

Carmen said...

funny i'm reading this now because i'm watching dr drew's sober house LOL
so WOW. awesome post. you have pointed out the number of similarities between you and i before (mostly physical) but i'm here to tell you and mentally we are alike as well :-) the difference is that you have the courage to admit and talk about things that i cannot. you definitely have as much or as little support you need from me!! but you rock. plain and simple :-)

tessierose said...

It's like you wrote my story, we have a lot in common, from the books to OA. I'm scared of myself more than anything and I hope I don't mess things up for myself. This was a great post, thank you for sharing.

Joey said...

Great Post. I've read most of Roth's books too, I really like her.

Niki said...

Unfortunately food is my drug of choice...blah!
I'm an addict. I swear I would get the same feeling of being high sometimes when I ate. It's my last addiction to overcome, but I know I can do it...we all can!!! =D

Jenny said...

Great post! I think that there is a little self doubt in all of us. I wonder whats going to happen when I get the band. Will I be able to succeed? But I really think that the blogging, and family support will help me. I think the fact that you recognize that it could be a problem for you is HUGE!!

Kristin said...

I really know the feeling of eating because I have to rather than because I want (or need) to. Great post.

Bonnie said...

If they ever do an addiction show of somebody addicted to reality shows you might see me on there. Very deep post. Thanks for sharing.

RC said...

LOL Bonnie! "addition show of somebody addicted to reality shows" I think there are a lot of us out there which is why these shows are so popular!
I loved the post - it help you to understand yourself better and I think there is a lot of people who do feel powerless against food. I like that analysis - because I often feel that way but feel much more in control now with the band. I think you're smart to get a fill. That was one of the biggest things I feel I did wrong. I waited almost 6 mos for my first fill b/c I was in some ways afraid to give up control - I still felt powerless over food - can you believe that? It really wasn't until this past September that I felt restriction for the first time and began making progress. I wish I'd done it sooner! Anyway great post and thanks for stopping by and commenting on my blog! I appreciate it!

Girl Bandit said...

Thanks for that post. It really sums up a lot of how I have felt before but I must say post band that bingeing..for me near impossible. And perhaps it may be that way for you when you get to a good spot. I might blog about it more on my blog....keep up the good work

The Vegan Pig said...

Isn't Geneen Roth amazing?? I just started her "Why Weight?" workbook after reading "When Food Is Love" and having it open up my mind to the deep-rooted and DISTURBING reasons that I use food in the way that I do. Realizing the reasons was a total shock to me and difficult to acknowledge, but I know I'm just experiencing growing pains - and I look forward to what will come at the end of this growth spurt!

Butterfly said...

Great post. I relate to so much of what you said and you've given me some food for thought.

I also did OA - and like every other attempt, it worked for a while and then eventually I would go back to the crazy bad habits. I always did the 'last food' thing too... including this time, and thinking about it now I realise that I never enjoyed it. I just did it because that is what I did. Also because of some ingrained fear that I'd never eat again... or something.

I think we've got the ultimate tool now, at least as good as is available to us -- and like every tool you have to learn to use it to get the most out of it, but this is the best chance we will get. And the best way to make the most of it is to work on the head while the band takes the pressure off the psychology that usually eats us up when we diet.

Am I even making sense?

amandakiska said...

Thank you all for your comments. I feel so much less crazy when I realize that I've hit a chord. I really feel strongly that we have all been made to feel that we are at fault because of our weight problems when there are really very few effective tools out there. I'm sort of filled with righteous indignation about the matter! I do like Geneen Roth a lot of have really enjoyed her work over the years. GB - The idea that I will be unable to binge again is like a dream come true, but I think you are right! With my current level of restriction, it would be hard to go on a real binge. Again, thank you all!